One of the Hamptons’ most distinctive and storied homes has returned to the market. Rosemary Lodge, a beautifully preserved Shingle-style residence built in 1884, is now listed for $14.25 million through Brown Harris Stevens agent Steven Dorn.
A Home With Deep Roots
Originally built by Reverend Henry Turbell Rose, the house sits on nearly one acre at 322 Rose Hill Road in Water Mill. Rose, who came from Lowell, Massachusetts, purchased the original half-acre plot from his uncle for just $50. He reportedly paid architect Frederick W. Stickney $25 for the house design and completed much of the construction himself.
“Rosemary Lodge is one of the last great legacy estates in the Hamptons,” Dorn says. “The craftsmanship and attention to detail are just not found in homes these days. It’s a very special place.”
In 1985, the home was relocated roughly 0.4 miles from its original site, closer to Montauk Highway. Architects R. Allan Cordingly and Elford A. King, who had owned the house for 20 years, moved it to its current location and reoriented the dwelling to face south. It now rests on a 0.93-acre parcel mere minutes from the ocean.
A Design That Stands the Test of Time
Added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2000, the home is considered a “museum-quality” example of Shingle-style architecture. It features early English and Craftsman influences, with asymmetrical lines and a rich, textured design.
The 4,110-square-foot home includes five bedrooms and four-and-a-half bathrooms. A renovation in 2007 maintained its original charm while adding modern touches like an in-ground pool and updated windows.
The listing describes the central living hall, paneled in ash, as setting the tone for the entire residence. Each room showcases a different type of wood, with details like hand-carved mantels, stained glass windows, and intricate moldings throughout the house.
Four fireplaces include unique features such as custom tile inserts, hidden cupboards, and hand-painted designs. Etched wood details show images of flowers, birds, ships, and butterflies, along with the initials “RL.”
“There is poetry literally carved into the walls, including works by Shakespeare,” Brown Harris Stevens notes.
Luxury Meets Legacy
The home also includes a chef’s eat-in kitchen with a professional gas stove, a large center island, and easy access to the outdoor dining area. The second-floor primary suite offers a spa-like bathroom, a walk-in closet, and a terrace overlooking the grounds.
The property has a rose garden, a lush backyard, and a heated pool. A pool house includes a full bathroom and shower, while an outdoor cooking area features a refrigerator and vegetable garden.
Additional highlights include a film-development darkroom, a gym shed, ample storage, and an electric vehicle charging station.
“This architectural treasure offers the rare chance to own a piece of Hamptons history, blending timeless elegance with modern luxury,” the listing concludes.
Records show the home last sold in 2004 for $2.75 million.
